Tahlequah Daily Press


February 17, 2014

Eliminating legal notice publication in papers a disservice to taxpayers

TAHLEQUAH — Every few years, a state legislator tries to nullify the long-standing requirement to publish county legal notices in newspapers. Advocates point out how much time and money counties can save if they don’t have to publish a synopsis of their activities, and hint the windfall could be used to buy a new road grader and hire an employee to drive it.

But they never mention that mandatory printing of legal notices is the only direct and reliable way the public can hold elected officials accountable. And as any long-term Oklahoma resident can attest, transparency is critical when it comes to the state’s 231 county commissioners.

The commissioner scandal of the late ‘70s and early ‘80s might not be on many minds today, but it was center stage at the time. More than 200 people were indicted in across-the-board kickback schemes; some were vendors, but most were commissioners who were fattening their wallets at taxpayer expense. One of Cherokee County’s own went down in flames, along with the other crooks.

Okies have long memories, but they can be murky, so many folks think the law requiring legal publication was enacted as a result of this widespread corruption. Just the opposite is true: Had the law not existed then, investigators could not have collected the documentation to prove wrongdoing. In almost all cases, the offending commissioners destroyed the damning records; the evidence needed to bring them to justice was instead found in newspaper archives across the state.

The most recent attempt to subvert transparency, HB 2445, was introduced this session. While past proposals have tried to eliminate the publication requirement altogether, HB 2445 was not overtly aimed at blocking access to information, but was  designed to change its method of delivery. It would have allowed commissioners to publish legal notices on newspaper websites, rather than in print editions, on the assumption that online publication would be cheaper. The logic isn’t necessarily sound, because newspapers could still charge the maximum amount allowable by law. So if the impetus was to prevent papers from profiting, or to recoup cash for county coffers, HB 2445 was a wash. Newspapers could still exact their pound of flesh; the loser in this scenario is the taxpaying public.

Not all newspapers have websites, and even those with the most state-of-the-art online presence still can’t guarantee absolute security. It’s possible for an outside hacker, or an employee, to alter content. Furthermore, if a newspaper changes its website vendor, it may lose its archives. And even when archives are available, a reader has to know what he’s looking for before he can find it. In short, it’s neither full-proof nor convenient for this purpose. The print edition is still the only way a newspaper can be absolute in exercising its duty as a government watchdog. Once something’s in print, it’s there to stay, and it’s actively “pushed” to the public, rather than passively awaiting attempts at access.

The watchdog role, more than anything else, is why newspapers with trained staffs will always play a vital role in society. Most public officials realize this, even if they don’t like it – and that’s why we were so disappointed to hear District 1 Cherokee County Commissioner Doug Hubbard saying just the opposite on a Tulsa TV station.

Hubbard told the reporter the Press charged the commissioners more for recent legal publications than in years past. The report was a bit deceptive because it cited a figure paid “just this year,” without clarifying the county’s “fiscal year”  starts in July. But the Press only did what many other publications do, and assessed the legal rate established by the state Legislature. That rate hasn’t changed in nine years, so if the county paid far less in the past, it’s been getting a real bargain.

But where we really take issue with Hubbard is something else he said: “... Newspapers are dwindling, the use of them... and it’s not getting any better... this is an opportune time to get some of this stuff started.” He employed the usual argument, saying the money paid for legal notices could have funded the salaries of two employees, one of whom could design a website. That seemed to indicate he wants the county to develop its own online vehicle for legal publications. In light of state history, we’re sure he will forgive us for suggesting that’s like hiring the fox to guard the henhouse.

Hubbard’s assertion that newspapers are “dwindling” must be based on purported trends of metro publications, because the Press, like many other community newspapers, has maintained a stable subscriber base for years, and is even logging growth. But if newspapers are “dying,” why did billionaire Warren Buffett purchase the Tulsa World? Why did Amazon founder Jeff Bezos buy the Washington Post? These men didn’t make their fortunes by pouring money into losing ventures.

The most qualified person to speak on this topic is Mark Thomas, executive director of the Oklahoma Press Association. Thomas is a true champion for government transparency, and here’s what he had to say: “Printed notices in local newspapers keep government accountable and keep citizens informed about the actions of their government. Plus, the money paid for these notices help newspapers provide more coverage of government activities. Maybe that’s why some public officials want notices eliminated.”

We’re not lumping Hubbard into that category. Perhaps he really believes newspapers are irrelevant, but he might change his mind if he engaged in questionable activities. It’s a sure bet the Press would eventually find out, and we’d tell his constituents.

Hubbard might also believe the county can’t “afford” to pay for legal publication. But there’s a bit of irony in the fact that Cherokee County commissioners, with their salaries in excess of $52,000, make nearly twice as much as the average journalist in this region – and for that matter, more than the average teacher. Commissioners don’t have to show up for work if they don’t want to, nor are they required to have college degrees – and most don’t. All teachers must have degrees, and most journalists have degrees or at least some college credits, and if they don’t show up, they get sacked.

Legislators may have had some of these things in mind last week when they let HB 2445 slide by – to the chorus of crickets – and likely rendered it moot for another year. Or maybe they decided against taking on a collective entity that buys ink by the barrel. Either way, they did the public a favor.

Transparency and accountability in county government – where it is needed more than just about anywhere else – has survived another day. For that, we should all be thankful.

Text Only
  • Ban on wage hikes by municipalities a mark of hypocrisy

    The words “God” and “governor” may share the same first two letters, but the two are hardly interchangeable.
    But let’s assume Gov. Mary Fallin really isn’t deluded enough to place her powers on the level of a deity. What rationale would a woman who has championed smaller government and local control use to explain her hypocrisy in banning individual Oklahoma cities from raising minimum wages in their jurisdictions?

    April 18, 2014

  • Community cleanups a good way to ensure our collective success

    This is our community – and it’s no better than what we make it. Let’s make it look great.

    April 16, 2014

  • Attack at school in Pennsylvania: Mental illness root of problem

    Washington’s crusade against guns was dealt a severe blow on Wednesday. No, it wasn’t the Supreme Court curtailment of the Second Amendment right of all Americans to own firearms. It wasn’t an executive order handed down by the administration. It was the brutal assault by a high school student in Pennsylvania against his fellow students – with a knife.

    April 14, 2014

  • People with faulty zippers should be booted from office

    We may forgive, but we shouldn’t forget, because there’s serious work to do in Washington. That work will never be accomplished as long as flawed zippers - literally or figurately – are a pervasive problem.

    April 11, 2014

  • Do your part to fight animal and child abuse

    It’s hard to change the habits of an abuser, especially when mitigating factors – such as alcohol or drugs – are involved. And these patterns tend to repeat themselves in successive generations. But all of us can take one small step to help eradicate this epidemic, and that is to report it when we see it.

    April 9, 2014

  • NSA head lies to Congress, and seems to get away with it

    Is there an obvious pattern of criminality within these governmental agencies? If so, why isn’t the Judicial Department investigating?

    April 7, 2014

  • Pass for rich kiddie rapist proves that justice isn’t blind

    Someone in Wilmington, Del., needs to keep an eye on Superior Court Judge Jan Jurden for the next few months, because she might improve her standard of living due to a sudden influx of cash.
    There’s no other way to explain why Jurden would have sentenced an ultra-wealthy heir to the du Pont fortune to probation for raping his 3-year-old daughter. It’s an outrageous miscarriage of justice that once again proves when it comes to the U.S. justice system, the elite get a pass almost every time.

    April 4, 2014

  • Maybe it’s not $3.2B, but state should still account for tribal cash

    In an editorial published last week, the Daily Press said that through tribal compacts, the state of Oklahoma received about $3.2 billion in annual revenue, partly attributable to the 117 casinos (or 118, in some reports) run by 33 tribes in the state. The information we accessed for that piece was confusing, and had a typo or two, which may have led us to overstate – to a considerable degree – how much money the tribes actually give the state.

    April 2, 2014

  • Tribal compacts should mean state has money to perform its functions

    Oklahoma should be rolling in the dough. The statistics bear that out. Thirty-three American Indian tribes operate 117 casinos in this state. Thanks to “compacts,” these tribes have been sharing the wealth with the state of Oklahoma. And thanks to the casinos, that wealth is substantial.

    March 28, 2014

  • It’s time to turn in your candidate announcements

    If you are running for a political office for which Cherokee County voters can cast ballots, it’s time to turn in your announcement. We’ve already run a few, and expect several more. The primary elections are Tuesday, June 24, with the registration period to vote in this election closing Thursday, May 30.

    March 24, 2014


What to you think of a state Legislature proposal to forbid cities from raising the minimum wage? Choose the closest to your opinion.

The federal government should set the minimum wage across the board.
States should be allowed to raise their minimum wages, but not cities.
Both states and cities should be allowed to raise their minimum wages.
Cities should be allowed to raise their mimum wages, but not states.
There should be no minimum wage at all.
     View Results
Tahlequah Daily Press Twitter
Follow us on twitter
AP Video
Raw: Magnitude-7.2 Earthquake Shakes Mexico City Ceremony at MIT Remembers One of Boston's Finest Raw: Students Hurt in Colo. School Bus Crash Raw: Church Tries for Record With Chalk Jesus Raw: Faithful Celebrate Good Friday Worldwide Deadly Avalanche Sweeps Slopes of Mount Everest Police Arrest Suspect in Highway Shootings Drought Concerns May Hurt Lake Tourism Vermont Goat Meat Gives Refugees Taste of Home Calif. Investigators Re-construct Fatal Bus Cras Mayor Rob Ford Launches Re-election Campaign Appellate Court Hears Okla. Gay Marriage Case Author Gabriel Garcia Marquez Dead at 87 Chelsea Clinton Is Pregnant Flamingo Frenzy Ahead of Zoo Construction Crew Criticized Over Handling of Ferry Disaster Agreement Reached to Calm Ukraine Tensions Boston Bombing Survivors One Year Later