subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Sat, Nov 21 2009 

Resources

print this story   Print this story
  Post to del.icio.us

Published June 12, 2009 11:58 am - June 12, 2009

Freedmen a fed issue



Editor, Daily Press:

The disparate racial treatment of Native American Freedmen began and must end with Congress, not the courts.

Congress created the Dawes Rolls under the Allotment Act of 1887 to document tribal citizenship. The rolls discriminated against African-Native American offspring by labeling them Freedmen without documenting degree of Native American ancestry. Interracial Caucasian Native American offspring were identified by blood quantum to 1/32nd degree, creating a “paper bag” test for Native American identity, and reinforcing the stigma against anyone “tainted” by African blood.

Freedmen challenged their segregation from “Indians by Blood,” but in 1906 Congress barred the transfer of Freedmen to the “by-blood” rolls. Thus began a century of Freedmen litigation seeking equality with “Indians-by-Blood,” who were granted the advantage of using the Dawes Rolls for documenting lineage. Congress inflamed racial tensions by apportioning government benefits based on blood quantum rather than treaties and the historical context from which they arose. For example, Congress excluded Seminole Freedmen in apportioning money between Florida and Oklahoma Seminoles in the Seminole Indians Judgment Funds Act of 1990. This fractured relations between Oklahoman Seminole Freedmen and Seminole-by-Bloods, which ended with the BIA siding with tribal leaders in denying Freedmen their share.

The treatment of Seminole Freedmen underscores the arbitrary character of the Dawes Rolls. The Seminole Tribe coalesced in Florida from escaped slaves and indigenous peoples disenchanted with the Southern plantation system of slavery. Escaped slaves intermarried within Seminole society, and shared African methods of crop cultivation more suitable to Florida’s climate. Even Congress recognized their integral role, and unlike the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, and Creek, there was no legislative mandate to create separate rolls for Seminole Freedmen.

The issue is neither sovereignty nor blood quantum, but a core premise of the 14th Amendment: that when the government creates a discriminatory harm because of race, it has a duty to repair the lasting effects of that harm. In this instance, the harm is more insidious due to the initial bonding between African and Native Americans, and their common heritage as the two “involuntary” minorities.

Congress can facilitate the healing by reforming the law. First, the racial discrimination of the rolls must be repealed by affording all Freedmen Native Americans identical access to government benefits for “by-blood” Native Americans. Second, Congress must remove the economics underlying bias against Freedmen and increase grants to reflect full Freedmen citizenship. Only then can traditional tribal values be rescued from a blood fetishism fueled by perverse incentives that pit one disadvantaged group against another.

There is a certain irony in the fact that our founding fathers were inspired by the color-blind, egalitarian values of indigenous Americans, yet later legislated racial strife into the tribes in a way that persists.

Kevin James, Esq.

Former Columbia University Revson Fellow, New York



print this story    email this story   






autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Premier Guide
Premium Jobs

Help Wanted
Medical Technologist needed in Tahlequah, OK to, under limited supervision, perform blood tests in all areas of the labo...>MORE

Help Wanted
LPN: 10pm To 6am position open for our Long Term Care/ Medicare Facility. We offer competitive salary, 401k, health be...>MORE

Help Wanted
RN Quality Manager We are looking for a RN to fill a position in our Long Term care Nursing Home as part of a Quality Ma...>MORE

Help Wanted
Skelly School- Accepting applications for an Elementary Physical Education Teacher for the remainder of the 2009-10 scho...>MORE

Help Wanted
LPN/ Wound Care Nurse: We need a LPN for a full-time position for our Wound Care Nurse. Experience in Long Term Care a...>MORE

See all ads

Premium cars

Used Trucks for Sale
1992 Dodge Dakota $2,200. Call 207-2270...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Homes

House for Rent
2bdrm, furnished, Satellite TV and water included. Chicken Creek $500 monthly, 740-0039...>MORE

House for Sale
Cute 2bdrm, 1ba, remodeled with new paint, carpet, etc. Custom cabinets, 5 acres with pond. One mile South of Peggs. ...>MORE

House for Rent
Located in Town: Two bedroom, one bath $400 431-1154...>MORE

House for Sale
BRAND NEW HOME! Illinois River Ranch on 3 beautiful acres, 3BR/2BA, spacious open living plan, move-in ready, gated comm...>MORE

Duplex for Rent
1bdrm $265 mo references required 688-6570...>MORE

Mobile for Rent
3bdrm, 2b, large covered porch, $375. month, $250. deposit, 918-637-6182, 918-772-0792...>MORE

Mobile Homes For Rent:
2Bdrm Rent Now Get December Free! call or click for details 457-4100, www.rentoklahoma.net...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Extras

Commercial Property
Ed’s Service Station, 901 E. Downing, available for lease January 1, 2010. Contact Jim McSpadden (918)931-0227 or (918)...>MORE

Acreage For Sale:
3Acres +/- , Available for site built or new mobile home. Several tracts to choose from 6 miles +/- NW of Tahlequah H...>MORE

Acreage for Lease
apx 15 acres in town call 918-822-7084, 918-456-9424....>MORE

Camper for Sale
Camper Truck asking $3,500.00 call 918-207-9740...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index