subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Sun, Nov 08 2009 

Resources

print this story   Print this story
  Post to del.icio.us

Published October 01, 2008 10:04 am - A ruling in the Oklahoma attorney general’s case against the poultry industry Monday drew mixed reviews from those in the area with interest in the case.

Poultry ruling gets mixed reviews; OSRC official and AG trade shots


By TEDDYE SNELL
Staff Writer

TAHLEQUAH DAILY PRESS

A ruling in the Oklahoma attorney general’s case against the poultry industry Monday drew mixed reviews from those in the area with interest in the case.

U.S. District Judge Gregory K. Frizzell denied the state’s request for a preliminary injunction that would eliminate the spread of poultry waste as fertilizer within the Illinois River watershed.

Attorney General Drew Edmondson filed suit against 13 poultry companies in 2005, and the recent injunction was requested because he believed bacterial evidence gathered during the investigation proved a health hazard to the general public.

In his ruling, Frizzell said the state’s expert witnesses’ work was not “sufficiently reliable,” and the work had not been “peer-reviewed or published.”

“The evidence produced to this court reflects that fecal bacteria in the waters of the IRW come from a number of sources, including cattle manure and human waste from growing numbers of human septic systems in that area’s ... topography,” wrote Frizzell. “The record reflects levels of fecal bacteria at similar levels in rivers and streams throughout the state of Oklahoma, including waterways in whose watersheds the record does not evidence similar application of poultry waste.”

Edmondson said the ruling will not affect the case against the poultry companies, based on the phosphorous levels, and will go to court in September 2009. Edmondson believes the request for the injunction, however, was justified.

“We felt there were human health implications from the bacterial information we discovered, and felt obliged to bring that to the court,” said Edmondson.

Kurt Robinson, president of Save The Illinois River, wasn’t completely surprised by the ruling.

“The decision by Judge Frizzell is a little disappointing, but not totally unexpected,” said Robinson. “The burden of proof for the state was very high because of technical, cutting-edge science used in identifying genetic markers for bacteria, as presented by the state’s witness.”

Robinson said it is interesting to note the decision comes on the heels of two recent national reports – including one from the U.S. Government Accounting Office – specifying numerous water bodies in northwest Arkansas and northeastern Oklahoma that have been impaired by manure from animal feeding operations, identifying these locations as areas of general ground water concern.

“The National Commission on Industrial Farm Animal Protection... warned us that manure from concentrated animal feeding operations containing nutrients, chemicals and micro-organisms is a major concern to our waterways, lakes, ground water, soils and airways, nationwide,” said Robinson. “STIR remains optimistic about the future of the Illinois River because of the efforts of Oklahoma to protect it from excess poultry waste.”

Bev Saunders, an area farmer and member of Poultry Partners, a grower’s consortium, was happy with the outcome.

“We are encouraged and obviously pleased with this ruling,” said Saunders. “The injunction hearing hasn’t changed the way farmers do business. Farmers continue to follow the laws, rules and regulations in their respective states.”

Oklahoma Scenic Rivers Commissioner for Adair County Rick Stubblefield had stern comments about the judge’s ruling.

“Ultimately, the court believed the professionals who work for water quality agencies for the state of Oklahoma,” said Stubblefield.



print this story    email this story   






autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Premier Guide
Premium Jobs

Help Wanted
Need Human Resources/ Payroll person, PT Temporary Clerical person. Bring resume to LaFerry’s Propane Keys across from ...>MORE

Help Wanted
Rehabilitation counselor needed. Must have Bachelor’s Degree in a Mental Health related field or degree in Criminal Jus...>MORE

Help Wanted
Are you unhappy with your current job?  Are you looking for a company that values their employees?  Then BIOS is the pla...>MORE

Help Wanted
PART-TIME HELP NEEDED in income tax preparation. Computer skills necessary, tax experience preferred. Send resume to 303...>MORE

Help Wanted
Cherokee County 911 Trust Authority is seeking qualified applicants for the position of 911 Coordinator. GENERAL SUMMARY...>MORE

Help Wanted
THERAPIST (Grove, OK) GRAND LAKE MENTAL HEALTH CENTER Providing Outpatient Behavioral Health Services.  Requires Masters...>MORE

See all ads

Premium cars

Auto For Sale
1994 Ford Ranger XLT. Super condition $1250 cash. 918-718-4319...>MORE

Auto For Sale
97 Tahoe Lt, 4 WD, dual air, lots of extras. 456-5604...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Homes

Houses/Apartments
Davis Rentals: Senior Houses and Retirement Apartments;
All Appliances, 456-4000
...>MORE

Duplex For Rent:
3bdrm Duplex Camelot 456-1243 or 457-0320...>MORE

House for Rent
Avail Oct 1, 3 bdrm 1 bth very small near HW51 Dollar Thrifty 431-2226...>MORE

House for Rent
One Bedroom, 318 Goingsnake, $300 Rent, $300 Deposit. Walking Distance to NSU 931-7929...>MORE

House for Rent
3bdrm, 2bth nice house in nice neighborhood, 509 West Shawnee, $400 deposit, Mark 718-4175...>MORE

House for Rent
2bdrm, furnished, Satellite TV and water included. Chicken Creek $500 monthly, 740-0039...>MORE

Mobile Homes For Sale
Special Government Program: Zero Down, No money out of your pocket!! If you own land or family will give you land. Bad C...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Extras

Commercial Property
1,800 sf office/ Retail next to Check-N-Go call 931-8386...>MORE

Acreage For Sale:
3Acres +/- , Available for site built or new mobile home. Several tracts to choose from 6 miles +/- NW of Tahlequah H...>MORE

Wanted To Buy:
Cash for Junk or
Unwanted cars. Quick
income. Call 456-4753
...>MORE

Lots For Sale:
Owner near Lake Tenkiller and Golf Course. Lots starting at $4,500, $300 down and $43.35 monthly. RV and Mobile lots a...>MORE

Commercial Property
8,400 sf retail space 4th Street and Muskogee, call 931-8386...>MORE

Acerage For Sale
Owner finance 10 acres 5 miles east of Peggs on 82C $22,000 $1,000 down $210 monthly 530-0885...>MORE

Commercial Property
Restaurant for lease (formally Runts) call 931-8386...>MORE

Acreage for Sale
apx 15 acres in town call 918-822-7084, 918-456-9424....>MORE

Commercial Property
Retail/ Office Space 600 sf to 8,400 sf call 931-8386...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index