Tahlequah Daily Press

Local News

March 20, 2013

Jury selection varies by attorney, court

TAHLEQUAH — When attorney Gayle McNamara came to Cherokee County from Los Angeles several years ago, she quickly realized there was a world of difference between the legal systems here and there.

Back in Los Angeles, McNamara said, courts handled hundreds of trials every day, many of them dealing with a great amount of money. When money was a prime consideration, attorneys on either side would often spend large sums on consulting firms to research and develop tactics for jury selection.

“They will actually go to the extent of doing a dry run – picking a jury – for the upcoming trial to give the clients and the attorneys a chance to get a preview of how it might go,” said McNamara.

But in Cherokee County, McNamara – now an attorney with the nonprofit Cherokee County Legal Services – hasn’t seen a case yet where a consulting firm was hired to help with jury selection. Here, things seem to be done on a much smaller scale, and attorneys have their own methods of picking the right jurors.

Trial dockets here are also held only a handful of times each year.

Weeks before scheduled jury dockets in Cherokee County, Court Clerk Shelly Kissinger’s office will check to see how many potential jurors are requested – which is typically around 300, or up to 350 if the docket includes murder cases.

The Administrative Office of the Court will then use a computer program to randomly pull that number of potential jurors. While many people believe those selections are still made from voter-registration records, they are actually chosen through records of driver’s licenses, Kissinger said.

Each potential juror will receive a summons, along with a letter that can be completed by a particular date if the individual feels he or she should be excused from jury duty. Some will be excused by the judge before the docket begins, but others will be required to show up at the courthouse at the start of the docket.

If potential jurors end up in a courtroom, they’ll be subjected to what the legal system refers to as “voir dire,” which could include a series of deeply personal questions that touch on previous criminal activity, family matters, career issues, and a host of other subjects directly or indirectly related to the case or the ability to serve on the panel.

In some instances, a judge may begin the process by asking his or her own questions of potential jurors; then, the attorneys – in a criminal case, the prosecutors and defense attorneys – may be allowed to ask questions of the jurors. Throughout the process, men and women can be excused from the jury pool for various reasons.

District 27 First Assistant District Attorney Jack Thorp believes voir dire is the most important part of a jury process.

“When picking a jury, you want jurors who can collaborate to find a verdict, to find the truth,” said Thorp.

When Thorp first began his legal career, he spent little time talking with and asking questions of the panelists, he said.

“I had a lot of real short voir dires, and I had a lot of not-so-great verdicts,” said Thorp.

But over the years, he began to study the process and developed his own method with a common set of questions for the jury. Depending on the facts of a case, he’ll then modify or add to the list of questions.

“Jurors want to know what they are doing is important,” said Thorp. “I treat voir dire as probably the most important part of the jury trial.”

Thorp developed his own voir dire process that incorporates a “positive” and “negative” approach to each potential juror. He keeps notes, and will ultimately rank jurors.

Other attorneys have their own ways of doing business.

“Attorneys have a lot of different attitudes about picking a jury,” said McNamara. “Some attorneys don’t think there’s really any scientific way to do it; they simply use their gut feelings and their intuition and their understanding about people.”

McNamara was able to serve on three juries before she became a lawyer in California, and she uses that experience to her advantage. In Oklahoma, attorneys are automatically excused from serving as jurors, she said. Attorneys who went into that career early in life may never know what it’s like to sit on a jury.

“I’ve learned that stereotypes and assumptions are sometimes true, but they’re frequently not,” said McNamara. “How do I pick jurors? I spend as much time as I can listening to them. I ask open-ended questions, and I encourage the jurors to talk about their attitudes, their feelings regarding the issues of the case, and I try to listen to what they’re saying without any preconceptions.”

McNamara’s goal is to always find someone who is “fair.”

“A lot of people are under the impression that one side or the other is stacking the jury – and in a sense, you are, in that you are looking for jurors who will understand your client’s situation,” she said.

“A prosecutor wants somebody to understand how important it is to fight crime; the defense wants a juror who’s going to understand how it’s possible for an ordinary person to get into this sort of situation. But I truly don’t think either side is trying to do anything other than obtain a fair trial. Maybe I’m idealistic, but my experience with the trial system is that it’s extremely effective.”

Attorneys use voir dire to eliminate jurors who might be prejudiced to the situation of the case, or toward someone involved in the case. This typically leads to jurors being asked about their friends, their family, and their personal lives and histories.

“An attorney is looking for bias, and bias is an extremely personal thing,” said McNamara. “Our Constitution guarantees people a trial by jurors who don’t have preconceptions. To find a fair jury, you have to probe a little bit into the sensitive areas. It’s always done in a way that respects the juror, but the purpose is to uncover either intentional or subconscious bias the person may have against the client, or the attorneys, or the people involved, to guarantee the defendant gets a fair trial. We all have strong feelings about one thing or another, and sometimes if we’re deeply committed, that can color our objectivity.”

After questioning of the potential jurors ends, attorneys from both sides may gather with the judge and pick the final jury that will hear the case. Thorp said each side is granted a certain number of “strikes” to eliminate potential jurors from the list. For a homicide case in district court, it’s nine strikes each, or five each in a non-homicide felony case, he said.

Processes may differ by judge, and based on where the case is being tried, whether it’s at the local level or in federal court.

McNamara – who represents clients in both civil and criminal cases – believes the jury selection process may not be perfect, but ultimately presents an “ideal and unique situation.”

“You have a group of people who don’t have an ax to grind, probably for the first time in their lives,” said McNamara. “This is not their work, it’s not their relatives, it’s not their friends. They don’t have any personal stake in the outcome, and I can’t think of any other situation in life where you are in that kind of an environment. My experience, both from being on a jury and from seeing the outcome of the jurors’ deliberations, is that it creates about as perfect a way to get to the bottom of the matter as exists, which isn’t to say there aren’t injustices. We know that innocent people are convicted from time to time, but I can’t think of a way to prevent it that would be any better than what we have right now.”

1
Text Only
Local News
  • CN, UKB battle over trust land application

    Two Tahlequah-based tribes presented oral arguments Friday in a protracted fight over a land-in-trust application.

    Over the course of five hours, attorneys for the Cherokee Nation, United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians, Cherokee Nation Entertainment and the Department of the Interior made their cases before Northern District Judge Gregory Frizzell in a hearing that was originally scheduled for February.

     

    July 25, 2014

  • ts-NSU-Main-1-a.jpg No NSU pool, for now

    NSU experiencing delays in fitness center construction

    Earlier this month, Northeastern State University announced it is experiencing delays in the renovation of its fitness center and pool.
    The facility was officially shuttered Sept. 17, 2012, and at the time, the projected completion date for renovation was this fall.

    July 25, 2014 3 Photos

  • jn-Suspect-1.jpg Officials: Images of suspects may help nab church burglars

    Cherokee County investigators hope surveillance footage captured around the Crescent Valley Baptist Church in Woodall helps lead to the suspects accused of breaking into the complex and setting fire to one building this week.
    According to Undersheriff Jason Chennault, cameras captured footage of two suspects on bicycles early Tuesday morning, July 22.

    July 25, 2014 2 Photos

  • svw-movie-night.jpg Local library hosts family movie night

    Nova Foreman and her two daughters were about to leave the Tahlequah Public Library Thursday, when they saw the Family Movie Night flyer.
    The three decided to stay and enjoy a movie they had not yet seen at the free, theater-like event.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • svw-Keys.jpg Grant to fund stepped-up Keys PE program

    Kair Ridenhour’s new office is filled with pedometers.
    Ridenhour officially started his new position as assistant elementary principal at Keys Public Schools on July 1.
    But his other role at the school – that of physical education project coordinator – prompted the influx of pedometers.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • jn cvbc fire.jpg Church catches fire after burglaries

    Authorities are looking for the person accused of breaking into the Crescent Valley Baptist Church two times this week and likely causing a fire that damaged the youth building early Wednesday morning.

    July 24, 2014 2 Photos

  • svw Humane photo.tif More volunteers needed to house strays, help with spay-and-neuter

    Furry friends may seem like the perfect addition to round out a family.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Marijuana, seeds lead to four arrests

    Four people were arrested on marijuana related charges early Wednesday morning after a traffic stop on South Muskogee Avenue.

    July 24, 2014

  • Sex offender found living in tent at river

    Cherokee County sheriff’s investigators arrested a convicted sex offender this week when they discovered he has been living in a tent along the river.

    July 24, 2014

  • ts-NSU-MAIN.jpg Fledgling RiverHawks arrive

    Over 200 incoming freshmen took part in orientation class at Northeastern State University

    July 23, 2014 1 Photo

Poll

Do you believe school administrators and college presidents in Oklahoma are paid too much?

Strongly agree.
Somewhat agree.
Somewhat disagree.
Strongly disagree.
Undecided.
     View Results
Tahlequah Daily Press Twitter
Follow us on twitter
AP Video
Raw: Corruption Trial Begins for Former Va Gov. The Carbon Trap: US Exports Global Warming UN Security Council Calls for Gaza Cease-fire Traditional African Dishes Teach Healthy Eating 13 Struck by Lightning on Calif. Beach Baseball Hall of Famers Inducted Israel, Hamas Trade Fire Despite Truce in Gaza Italy's Nibali Set to Win First Tour De France Raw: Shipwrecked Concordia Completes Last Voyage Raw: Sea Turtle Hatchlings Emerge From Nest Raw: Massive Dust Storm Covers Phoenix 12-hour Cease-fire in Gaza Fighting Begins Raw: Bolivian Dancers Attempt to Break Record Raw: Israel, Palestine Supporters Rally in US Raw: Air Algerie Flight 5017 Wreckage Virginia Governor Tours Tornado Aftermath Judge Faces Heat Over Offer to Help Migrant Kids Kangaroo Goes Missing in Oklahoma More M17 Bodies Return, Sanctions on Russia Grow Raw: Deadly Tornado Hits Virginia Campground
Stocks