Tahlequah Daily Press

Local News

February 17, 2014

Constitution’s language is its strength

The first in an ongoing series about the document and its amendments

TAHLEQUAH — It is the supreme law for 300 million people, even if it was a do-over. It has influenced the formation of governments in other nations, though those directly governed by it often bicker over what it means.

The Constitution of the United States of America is the oldest document of its kind. There are older written documents that still hold legal force, such as the Magna Carta of 1215 and the Statutes of San Marino, written in 1600. But the U.S. Constitution is the oldest single-source document still in effective use.

While all of the founders took part in creating the Constitution, James Madison gets the lion’s share of credit as the author. Alexander Hamilton and John Jay also receive much acknowledgement.

The three were members of the Constitutional Convention of 1787, a gathering of state delegates who met for the “sole and express purpose of revising the Articles of Confederation” and Perpetual Union.

The more the framers looked at the Articles and their Congress, the more they didn’t like them. Sentiment grew for an effectual central government, and the Articles were thrown out.

After much compromise between the 13 colonies and a laborious three-year ratification process which produced the Bill of Rights, the Constitution went into effect for all of the United States with Rhode Island’s ratification in May 1790.

It is a short document - the shortest constitution in the world. Its brevity has been troublesome, but also might be the key to its endurance.

“Article 1 permits Congress to tax and spend to further the ‘general welfare,’” said Dr. Daniel Savage, chairman of the Department of Geography, Political Science and Sociology at Northeastern State University.

“General welfare as been reinterpreted throughout our history. Article 2 gives the president ‘executive power’ but never defines this power nor spells out precise limits to it. Article 3 neither defines nor limits the ‘judicial power’ of the Supreme Court. There is a flexibility that a more detailed and precise document would lack.”

State Rep. Mike Brown said the framers realized the world changes and that the United States would need a “living document,” but also gave the Constitution some rigidity.

“They deliberately made the amendment process difficult to prevent changes made strictly for political reasons,” he said. “An amendment must receive two-thirds of a vote in Congress and be ratified by three-fourths of the state legislatures. But change is possible.”

There are many other ambiguities. Who are “the people?” In the 1780s, the people were white male landowners at least 21 years of age.

“I would like to believe that even though some of our Founding Fathers were slaveowners and bigots, they really did leave room for future generations that may interpret words differently,” said Dana Rogers, Democratic party chairwoman for Cherokee County. “In no way can I attempt to understand their mindset, because in my mind people are simply human. But considering the change these men saw just in their own lifetimes, I hope they wanted enough ambiguity to allow the document to survive.”

Dr. Shannon Grimes, Republican party chairman for Cherokee County, agreed there is some uncertainty in the text, but believes there are plenty of contemporary writings to provide context.

“The Federalist and Anti-Federalist papers, and others, shed a great deal of light on what was meant when the words were written,” he said. “The limitations placed on our national government by the Constitution are often circumvented. Many pay lip service to the Constitution, but I’m afraid there are few, particularly in government, that value the context and spirit in which the words were intended.”

Denise Deason-Toyne, an attorney and president of Save the Illinois River Inc., said the 1780s were a time of “rapid changes in philosophies and social ideologies.”

“It made sense to draft a document which could be interpreted differently rather than amended,” she said. “Amendments take a long time. Moreover, if the language had been more specific, the failure to state something could be interpreted today as ‘if they didn’t say it, then they didn’t want it included.’ An example is the right to privacy. We have some expectations of privacy, though there is no specific mention in the Constitution or the Bill of RIghts. They have been interpreted to provide that right.”

In the coming months, the Tahlequah Daily Press will publish stories relating to the Constitution and its amendments.

srowley@tahlequahdailypress.com

1
Text Only
Local News
  • ts-Trail-show-1.jpg Jackson takes prize

    Cherokee Heritage Center Museum Curator Mickel Yantz kicked off his 10th anniversary at the venue with the opening of the 43rd annual Trail of Tears Art Show this past Friday.
    “The Trail of Tears show was my first exhibit opening when I arrived 10 years ago,” said Yantz. “Since that time, the show has changed so dramatically; we’ve added so many new artists, and the art work has excelled over time. It’s like Christmas for me.”
    Yantz said he was exceptionally pleased with the opening reception.
    “We had a fantastic turnout,” said Yantz. “We had a lot of fun and sold some artwork, which is great for opening night.”
    The exhibit is on display at the Cherokee Heritage Center through May 26. This year’s show features 130 pieces of art spanning eight different categories, including basketry, graphics, jewelry, miniature, painting, pottery and sculpture.

    April 16, 2014 2 Photos

  • churchguy.jpg Some NSU students find Church of Monett offensive

    They turn heads every time they show up on campus, and some students at Northeastern State University are offended by their presence.
    The Church of Monett, Mo., has made periodic trips to Tahlequah to stage quiet demonstrations in public campus spaces in recent years. They carry signs that read, “Wives, Obey your Husbands,”; “To be Married to the divorced is Adultery”; and “Don’t be deceived: fornicators homosexuals idolaters adulterers thieves drunkards - shall not inherit God’s Kingdom.”

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Teen sent to hospital after being struck by tractor-trailer

    An 18-year-old Tahlequah man was struck by a tractor-trailer early Tuesday morning on the State Highway 51 bypass near Mimosa Lane.
    Tahlequah Police Capt. Tom Jones said officers responded to the scene at about 5:40 a.m., when Sage Sohns was found injured and lying in the road. A medical helicopter responded to the scene to transport Sohns to a Tulsa hospital, where he was being treated for a closed-head injury, police said.

    April 16, 2014

  • TPS board hears architect presentations for cafeteria

    Members of the Tahlequah Public Schools Board of Education heard from four architectural firms seeking a contract for construction at Cherokee Elementary School.
    TPS plans to build a cafeteria-auditorium and a music room with a stage, which may also serve as a safe room during storms.

    April 16, 2014

  • Briggs.jpg Local man hit with assault, burglary charges

    Prosecutors have formally charged a Tahlequah man accused of breaking into a motel room, tying a rope around a man’s neck and stabbing him repeatedly with a syringe.
    Jimmy Dale Briggs Jr., 33, is charged with first-degree burglary, assault and battery with a dangerous weapon, and two counts of threatening to perform an act of violence.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Boy whose mom scolded deputies in trouble again

    Cherokee County sheriff’s deputies arrested a 15-year-old theft suspect Monday night after he allegedly assaulted his brother.
    Deputy Kim Novak said authorities were dispatched to a home and ultimately took the teen into custody. While there, they also discovered items that had been reported stolen, including a bed and several tools.
    Novak said the teen is the same boy who has previously been found to be in possession of stolen items.

    April 16, 2014

  • plane-crash-1-a.jpg Plane crash victims recovering

    Two Arkansas men remained in a Tulsa hospital Monday after the plane they were flying crashed into a wooded area in Cookson.
    According to the Federal Aviation Administration, the 1946 Ercoupe 415 crashed under “unknown circumstances” about a mile from the Tenkiller Air Park in Cookson Saturday morning.
    The Oklahoma Highway Patrol says 75-year-old John McCreary and 85-year-old Albert Demarco Jr., both of Ozark, Ark., were flown from Cookson to St. John Medical Center in Tulsa.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • walker-terrance.jpg Man taken for blood sample confuses hospital with hotel

    Tahlequah police say an Austin, Texas, man stopped Saturday mistook a local hospital for a hotel when he was taken to have his blood drawn.
    Officer Cory Keele’s affidavit says 20-year-old Terrance Walker was driving south on Muskogee Avenue at about 2 a.m. Saturday, swerving from one line to another.
    Keele tried to stop the car near Muskogee and Chickasaw, and Walker eventually slowed to a stop near South Street.
    Walker opened the car door as Keele approached. The officer said Walker had dilated pupils.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • ennis-scottie.jpg Knife-cutting incident lands man in jail

    A Tahlequah man jailed for allegedly cutting a woman with a kitchen knife was released on a recognizance bond Monday.
    Scottie Lee Ennis, 42, was arrested after Officer Austin Yates was sent to Tahlequah City Hospital late Friday night.
    There, Yates spoke with Jennifer Pennell, who had apparently suffered a stab wound to her arm.
    Pennell told Yates she and her husband, Ennis, had gone to Dewain’s Place earlier in the evening, and while at the bar, a man bought her a drink.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • hawley-jeremy.jpg Tahlequah man bonds out after arrest for assault

    A 22-year-old Tahlequah man bonded out of jail Monday after his weekend arrest on domestic assault charges.
    Jeremy Hawley was booked into jail Sunday for domestic assault and battery in the presence of a minor and interfering with a 911 call.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

Poll

What to you think of a state Legislature proposal to forbid cities from raising the minimum wage? Choose the closest to your opinion.

The federal government should set the minimum wage across the board.
States should be allowed to raise their minimum wages, but not cities.
Both states and cities should be allowed to raise their minimum wages.
Cities should be allowed to raise their mimum wages, but not states.
There should be no minimum wage at all.
Undecided.
     View Results
Tahlequah Daily Press Twitter
Follow us on twitter
AP Video
Stocks