Tahlequah Daily Press

Local News

May 25, 2012

Testimony in Butcher trial centers on evidence

TAHLEQUAH — Testimony given throughout the day Thursday in the first-degree murder case against Bronson William Butcher centered mostly on the state’s investigation of the case.

Jurors heard from special agents and criminalists with the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation, who testified about their probe into Dane Dunegan’s death and the processes used to identify and compare potential evidence.

Senior OSBI criminalist Joseph Orcutt specializes in forensic biology. He said he was responsible for comparing items seized after Dunegan’s death for possible DNA profile matches to Butcher or Dunegan.

A blood sample taken from a couch at Butcher’s duplex showed a DNA profile mostly matching Dunegan, Orcutt testified. He said it also had the profile of at least one other person’s DNA, but it wasn’t Butcher’s.

Swabs of blood found on the gearshift of a black Nissan car – which Butcher had borrowed from Muskogee friend Blake Rowan the day Dunegan was shot – had a DNA match for Butcher, Orcutt said, but not Dunegan. At least one other person’s DNA was on the gearshift, he said.

A sample of potential blood from that car’s front passenger floorboard matched Butcher’s DNA profile, but not Dunegan’s.

Orcutt also looked for comparisons on blood-like substances found on a left-foot shoe and a pair of blue jeans, both of which had been recovered at Butcher’s girlfriend’s home in a washing machine when Butcher was arrested. Former Cherokee County sheriff’s Investigator Matt Merideth testified that the items were wet when seized from the machine.

The DNA profile of the blood-like spot on the shoe matched neither Butcher’s nor Dunegan’s, Orcutt testified, but was identified as human DNA. The stain on the blue jeans provided a mixture of at least three people, Orcutt said, adding that Dunegan was excluded, but Butcher “could not be excluded.”

Butcher’s defense attorney, Donn Baker, asked Orcutt if he had been told to see if the DNA would match eyewitness Blake Gower, Rowan, or any other people. Orcutt said he had not.

Stormy Gibble, a senior OSBI criminalist who specializes in latent evidence, testified she analyzed a Sallisaw McDonald’s receipt recovered in the black Nissan, but was unable to collect fingerprints from the item. She said a “lift card” submitted by OSBI Special Agent Todd Spurlock, who investigated the scene of Dunegan’s death at Wisteria Lane, had a positive comparison to Butcher’s left little finger and left ring finger.

That fingerprint “lift” had reportedly been taken from a door at Butcher’s duplex.

Baker also called into question the arrest of Butcher at his girlfriend’s home. Merideth said he assisted in the arrest of Butcher and that he recalled Agent Ashley Stephens, of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, placing Butcher in Stephens’ truck after the arrest. Merideth said he heard Stephens provide Butcher with his Miranda rights, and that Butcher “advised he wanted to speak” to Stephens.

Merideth said Butcher told Stephens he’d met Dunegan the morning of the shooting, that Dunegan “tried to do something to him,” and that when the two “got into a fight,” it “went bad.”

Merideth said that conversation took place when Stephens and Merideth were transporting Butcher to the Cherokee County Detention Center. He also testified Butcher told officers he wasn’t under the influence of any substances, and hadn’t taken substances “in a while.” The conversation wasn’t tape-recorded, and officers didn’t ask Butcher to write his statement down at the time, Merideth said.

Baker questioned Merideth’s memory of the event, and pointed out the former investigator didn’t write a report following the incident in March 2011. Merideth said he wasn’t the lead investigator, and admitted he’d looked at other officers’ reports as a refresher of what happened last year.

“When you arrest a murder suspect, you remember most of the stuff that’s said,” Merideth told Baker during his testimony. “It’s not very often you do that.”

Merideth also testified he was with other officers who went to the home of Gower’s grandmother, where the black Nissan had been left by Butcher on March 15. Investigators had developed information that Butcher might be at the home, Merideth said.

Gower’s grandmother wasn’t home when they arrived, but Merideth said he recalled something was “wrong,” so officers entered the home without warrants and did a “protective sweep,” then left the house.

Merideth said officers saw a youth-sized .22-caliber rifle, which looked to be like a smaller youth-sized gun. Baker asked why agents didn’t take the rifle as possible evidence, since they had information that a similar gun had been used to shoot Dunegan. Merideth said the officers had been told the rifle used in Dunegan’s shooting was a pump-action weapon, and the rifle inside the home of Gower’s grandmother was a bolt-action.

Jurors were set to begin hearing a fourth day of testimony Friday at 9 a.m.

Click here to get the entire Tahlequah Daily Press delivered everyday to your home or office. Code for E-EDITION TRIAL OR SUBSCRIBE Click here to get a free trial or to subscribe to the Tahlequah Daily Press electronic edition.

It's the ENTIRE newspaper (without the paper) for your computer, iPad or e-reader.

Text Only
Local News
  • rf-poker-run-main.jpg Poker run

    Fundraiser was in the cards for local philanthropic group

    It was perfect weather, with temperatures in the high 80s Saturday, as boaters filled their vessels with friends for a fun afternoon on Lake Tenkiller. A crowd gathered at Cookson Bend Marina, and folks lined up to support a local charity event.
    As fundraisers go, the Beta Sigma Phi Mu Omega Poker Run last Saturday could be considered huge success, as nearly $9,000 was collected.

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • bilbrey-anthony.jpg Man arrested for blackmailing woman for sex

    Cherokee County sheriff’s deputies put a man behind bars Monday night after he allegedly tried to blackmail a woman by threatening to post nude photos of her on the Internet if she did not meet him for sex.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • Peach_photo_2.jpg Peach crop lean, but fruit still available

    Summer is all about peaches in Porter – especially at Livesay Orchard.
    The Livesay Orchard is still busy a week after Porter’s annual peach festival. The orchard’s crop this year was cut in half from what had previously been expected, according to Kent Livesay, one of the owners of the orchard.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • jackson-jaymee.jpg Tot’s injuries prompt abuse charges for two local residents

    A Tahlequah couple was formally charged Tuesday with child neglect and child abuse after an 18-month-old girl was found with a number of injuries.

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • proctor-micah.jpg Pair accused of threatening man

    Two men behind bars at the Cherokee County Detention Center are accused of wielding a knife and gun and assaulting a man at a trailer park on West Keetoowah Sunday afternoon.
    Tahlequah Officer Reed Felts spoke with Reinaldo Flores, who told officers he heard a knock on his door and went to answer it.

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • Reach Higher an innovative approach to college

    The “Reach Higher” degree completion program is helping many Oklahoma students go back to school without drastically changing their lives.
    “This program is designed for working adults,” said Tim McElroy, program coordinator at the NSU- Muskogee campus.

    July 30, 2014

  • City attorney, others questioned chamber use of tourism tax

    Letters written in 2006 by City Attorney Park Medearis to former city councilor and Tahlequah Area Tourism Council board member Jack Spears suggest money from a hotel-motel tax could be disbursed through an agent other than the Chamber of Commerce, without voter approval.

    July 30, 2014

  • Hulbert council discusses Internet service

    During a meeting Tuesday night, members of the Hulbert Town Council discussed the possibility of Lake Region Electric Cooperative’s extending its cable and Internet service.

    July 30, 2014

  • ts-marching-MAIN.jpg Marching in step

    Tahlequah High School Orange Express Marching Band kicks off 2014 season with summer drills.

    The Tahlequah High School Orange Express Marching Band has added 30-35 freshmen to its roster this year, and drills began for the newest members last Thursday.

    July 29, 2014 2 Photos

  • studie-roberta.jpg Woman accused of stealing cash, taking it to casino

    A 35-year-old Tahlequah woman is free on bond after she allegedly took $1,200 from a man who had been jailed for old warrants.
    Cherokee County sheriff’s deputies said they spoke with Jason Jones last week after Jones was arrested by park rangers for the outstanding warrants. Jones said he came to Oklahoma to see family, and when he was arrested, he left his wallet and cash with one of his daughters.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo


Do you believe school administrators and college presidents in Oklahoma are paid too much?

Strongly agree.
Somewhat agree.
Somewhat disagree.
Strongly disagree.
     View Results
Tahlequah Daily Press Twitter
Follow us on twitter
AP Video
Florida Panther Rebound Upsets Ranchers Small Plane Crash in San Diego Parking Lot Busy Franco's Not Afraid of Overexposure Fighting Blocks Access to Ukraine Crash Site Dangerous Bacteria Kills One in Florida Workers Dig for Survivors After India Landslide Texas Scientists Study Ebola Virus Smartphone Powered Paper Plane Debuts at Airshow Southern Accent Reduction Class Cancelled in TN Raw: Deadly Landslide Hits Indian Village Obama Chides House GOP for Pursuing Lawsuit New Bill Aims to Curb Sexual Assault on Campus Russia Counts Cost of New US, EU Sanctions 3Doodler Bring 3-D Printing to Your Hand Six PA Cops Indicted for Robbing Drug Dealers Britain Testing Driverless Cars on Roadways