Tahlequah Daily Press

Local News

May 25, 2012

Testimony in Butcher trial centers on evidence

TAHLEQUAH — Testimony given throughout the day Thursday in the first-degree murder case against Bronson William Butcher centered mostly on the state’s investigation of the case.

Jurors heard from special agents and criminalists with the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation, who testified about their probe into Dane Dunegan’s death and the processes used to identify and compare potential evidence.

Senior OSBI criminalist Joseph Orcutt specializes in forensic biology. He said he was responsible for comparing items seized after Dunegan’s death for possible DNA profile matches to Butcher or Dunegan.

A blood sample taken from a couch at Butcher’s duplex showed a DNA profile mostly matching Dunegan, Orcutt testified. He said it also had the profile of at least one other person’s DNA, but it wasn’t Butcher’s.

Swabs of blood found on the gearshift of a black Nissan car – which Butcher had borrowed from Muskogee friend Blake Rowan the day Dunegan was shot – had a DNA match for Butcher, Orcutt said, but not Dunegan. At least one other person’s DNA was on the gearshift, he said.

A sample of potential blood from that car’s front passenger floorboard matched Butcher’s DNA profile, but not Dunegan’s.

Orcutt also looked for comparisons on blood-like substances found on a left-foot shoe and a pair of blue jeans, both of which had been recovered at Butcher’s girlfriend’s home in a washing machine when Butcher was arrested. Former Cherokee County sheriff’s Investigator Matt Merideth testified that the items were wet when seized from the machine.

The DNA profile of the blood-like spot on the shoe matched neither Butcher’s nor Dunegan’s, Orcutt testified, but was identified as human DNA. The stain on the blue jeans provided a mixture of at least three people, Orcutt said, adding that Dunegan was excluded, but Butcher “could not be excluded.”

Butcher’s defense attorney, Donn Baker, asked Orcutt if he had been told to see if the DNA would match eyewitness Blake Gower, Rowan, or any other people. Orcutt said he had not.

Stormy Gibble, a senior OSBI criminalist who specializes in latent evidence, testified she analyzed a Sallisaw McDonald’s receipt recovered in the black Nissan, but was unable to collect fingerprints from the item. She said a “lift card” submitted by OSBI Special Agent Todd Spurlock, who investigated the scene of Dunegan’s death at Wisteria Lane, had a positive comparison to Butcher’s left little finger and left ring finger.

That fingerprint “lift” had reportedly been taken from a door at Butcher’s duplex.

Baker also called into question the arrest of Butcher at his girlfriend’s home. Merideth said he assisted in the arrest of Butcher and that he recalled Agent Ashley Stephens, of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, placing Butcher in Stephens’ truck after the arrest. Merideth said he heard Stephens provide Butcher with his Miranda rights, and that Butcher “advised he wanted to speak” to Stephens.

Merideth said Butcher told Stephens he’d met Dunegan the morning of the shooting, that Dunegan “tried to do something to him,” and that when the two “got into a fight,” it “went bad.”

Merideth said that conversation took place when Stephens and Merideth were transporting Butcher to the Cherokee County Detention Center. He also testified Butcher told officers he wasn’t under the influence of any substances, and hadn’t taken substances “in a while.” The conversation wasn’t tape-recorded, and officers didn’t ask Butcher to write his statement down at the time, Merideth said.

Baker questioned Merideth’s memory of the event, and pointed out the former investigator didn’t write a report following the incident in March 2011. Merideth said he wasn’t the lead investigator, and admitted he’d looked at other officers’ reports as a refresher of what happened last year.

“When you arrest a murder suspect, you remember most of the stuff that’s said,” Merideth told Baker during his testimony. “It’s not very often you do that.”

Merideth also testified he was with other officers who went to the home of Gower’s grandmother, where the black Nissan had been left by Butcher on March 15. Investigators had developed information that Butcher might be at the home, Merideth said.

Gower’s grandmother wasn’t home when they arrived, but Merideth said he recalled something was “wrong,” so officers entered the home without warrants and did a “protective sweep,” then left the house.

Merideth said officers saw a youth-sized .22-caliber rifle, which looked to be like a smaller youth-sized gun. Baker asked why agents didn’t take the rifle as possible evidence, since they had information that a similar gun had been used to shoot Dunegan. Merideth said the officers had been told the rifle used in Dunegan’s shooting was a pump-action weapon, and the rifle inside the home of Gower’s grandmother was a bolt-action.

Jurors were set to begin hearing a fourth day of testimony Friday at 9 a.m.

Click here to get the entire Tahlequah Daily Press delivered everyday to your home or office. Code for E-EDITION TRIAL OR SUBSCRIBE Click here to get a free trial or to subscribe to the Tahlequah Daily Press electronic edition.

It's the ENTIRE newspaper (without the paper) for your computer, iPad or e-reader.

Text Only
Local News
  • ts-camp-cherokee-main.jpg Camp Cherokee

    About 500 area youth attending popular camp for tribal citizens.

    In reality, two camps are taking place at the Camp Heart ‘o the Hills: a day camp for children in first through sixth grades, and a residential camp for those in middle and high school.

    July 22, 2014 2 Photos

  • leatherman-chad.jpg Man gets 20 years for robbing local Walgreens store

    A Tahlequah man accused of robbing a local Walgreens this year has received a 20-year sentence.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • svw-orphan-train.jpg ‘Orphan Train’ authors visit Tahlequah

    Imagine, for a moment, being a child whose parents could not care for him, and the only alternative was to ride the rails across the country, hoping to find a new family and home.
    For local resident Peggy Kaney’s grandfather, this scenario was a reality.
    Alison Moore and Phil Lancaster shared the stories of over 200,000 children taken from New York City and then given away to families in western states from 1854 to 1929, at the Tahlequah Public Library on July 17.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • City council gives family deadline to rehab property

    Tahlequah’s city council is giving a family with local ties a little more than a month to develop and submit rehabilitation plans for two pieces of property containing six dilapidated structures in the 400 block of Lee Street.
    Members of the city’s abatement board recommended the homes be demolished, according to Tahlequah Building Inspector Mark Secratt. City officials then sent a certified notice as required by law, but the letter was returned.

    July 22, 2014

  • Man ‘howling like dog,’ arrested for APC

    When a Kentucky man pulled into an area convenience store over the weekend and began “barking and howling like a dog,” sheriff’s deputies checked on him and eventually hauled him to jail on alcohol-related charges, an arrest report shows.

    July 22, 2014

  • Man stable after crash

    A 57-year-old Tahlequah man was listed in stable condition Sunday evening after a crash on Old Toll Gate Road in northern Cherokee County.

    July 22, 2014

  • svw-Marijuana-guy.jpg Grassroots efforts

    Group seeks area support to put medical marijuana on November ballot

    Legalized medical marijuana will be on the ballots in November if Oklahomans for Health, the organization putting forward the proposed amendment, can get 155,216 signatures by Aug. 16.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • washington-marshal.jpg Man charged following June pursuit

    Prosecutors have filed formal charges against a Hulbert man accused of leading authorities on a pursuit and running a roadblock last month.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • rf-3rd-Thurs-group.jpg Third Thursday downtown event gaining momentum

    Most new events take time to build a following and Third Thursday Art Walk is still gaining momentum.
    The cloudy weather may have kept some shoppers home, but those out were enjoying the evening and buying gifts.

    July 21, 2014 2 Photos

  • Council to mull TMSA contract

    Tahlequah city councilors on Monday are set to discuss and possibly act on a request to renew a contract with the local main street program worth $25,000 per year.
    If the contract is approved for the Tahlequah Main Street Association, it would automatically renew each year unless otherwise terminated or canceled.

    July 21, 2014


Do you believe school administrators and college presidents in Oklahoma are paid too much?

Strongly agree.
Somewhat agree.
Somewhat disagree.
Strongly disagree.
     View Results
Tahlequah Daily Press Twitter
Follow us on twitter
AP Video
Judge Ponders Overturning Colo. Gay Marriage Ban Airlines Halt Travel to Israel Amid Violence NYPD Chief Calls for 'use of Force' Retraining VA Nominee McDonald Goes Before Congress Bush: Don't Worry, Sugarland Isn't Breaking Up US Official: Most Migrant Children to Be Removed Police Probing Brooklyn Bridge Flag Switch CDC Head Concerned About a Post-antibiotic Era Raw: First Lady Says `Drink Up' More Water Courts Conflicted Over Healthcare Law Holder Urges Bipartisanship on Immigration Raw: Truck, Train Crash Leads to Fireball US Airlines Cancel Israel Flights Obama Signs Workforce Training Law Crash Victims' Remains Reach Ukraine-held City Diplomatic Push Intensifies to End War in Gaza Cat Fans Lap Up Feline Film Festival Michigan Plant's Goal: Flower and Die Veteran Creates Job During High Unemployment