Tahlequah Daily Press

Local News

August 27, 2012

Health care law may improve accountability

TAHLEQUAH — Medicare, the national insurance program administered by the federal government, provided health insurance to 48 million Americans in 2010. On average, it covered about half the health care costs for enrollees.

Since the passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010, speculation has swirled about the sustainability of the program and possible changes it might undergo.

Medicare insurance is divided into four parts: Parts A and B, which includes hospital care and outpatient care in an open-network system; Part C, which is Medicare Advantage, the entity’s own network in which the government pays for private health coverage; and Part D, which covers prescription medications.

State Sen. Jim Wilson, D-Tahlequah, receives Veterans Administration health benefits and is also a Medicare recipient. He is a proponent of PPACA, and said the law would not expand coverage, but will require recipients to receive “better treatment.”

“My wife and I are both on Medicare Part A, but we will continue to use Health Choice, the group plan for state employees, until the end of November, when I am no longer a state employee,” said Wilson. “I have been looking at our options for Part B, Part D and supplemental plans over the last couple of weeks in preparation [for retiring from being a state employee].”

Traditionally, Medicare pays for 80 percent of expenses incurred under Parts A and B, and recipients buy supplemental insurance to help with the remaining 20 percent.

“Typically, these supplements, with a $2,000 deductible, cost $23 to $40 per month, per person, depending on age,” said Wilson. “Without the deductible, you can figure an additional $115 to $220 per month – again, depending on age. Adding Part D [for prescription medications] costs another $30 to $50 per month. You are also liable for the $100 premium to Medicare, which is usually deducted from Social Security. Depending on age, you could easily spend $250 per month, per person, out of pocket. This does not change with PPACA.”

Wilson pointed out Medicare is structured to pay for “medically necessary” treatment, and is preferable to private insurance.

“PPACA is not expanding Medicare coverage per se,” said Wilson. “It is, however, going to require people get better treatment. For instance, Medicare spends $165 million per year in Oklahoma for hospital readmissions due to mistakes and poor followup. The real value of PPACA is Medicare will finally be paying for how well the patient does, instead of the number of unnecessary procedures.”

On March 20, 2010, the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office and the Joint Committee on Taxation issued cost estimates of PPACA as amended by the Reconciliation Act. The analyses indicated that provisions in PPACA will reduce direct spending by $511 billion over between 2010 and 2019, with Medicare accounting for about $390 billion of the reduction.

According to a report by the Congressional Research Service, in March each year, the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission makes update recommendations to Congress on Medicare’s different systems. To do that, MedPAC staff examines the adequacy of the Medicare payments for efficient providers.

“Several provisions in PPACA are consistent with MedPAC recommendations to provide adequate incentives to produce appropriate, high-quality care at an efficient price,” states the report. “For example, a provision in PPACA requires the establishment of a national, voluntary pilot program that will bundle payments for physicians and hospitals as well as post-acute care services with the goal of improving patient care and reducing spending. Another provision establishes rewards for accountable care organizations that meet quality-of-care targets and reduce costs per patient relative to a spending benchmark.”

Wilson said he’s seen positive  examples of this realignment here in Oklahoma.

“As an example, we have seen in Oklahoma that by reducing payments to hospitals by $1,600 and doctors by $200 for unnecessary cesarean or induced deliveries, the Health Care Authority, which is the Medicaid administrator, has achieved statistically healthier results for newborns carried to term,” said Wilson. “It’s all about the money. I think Medicare is ripe for this kind of improvement - pay for good and don’t pay for bad. Fully one-third of the [Medicare] cuts come from the Medicare Advantage program, which is nothing more than giving insurance companies at 14 to 17 percent premium for administering Medicare. It does not do away with Medicare Advantage, but does freeze payments and reimburses on better results instead of volume.”

Traditional Medicare insures those qualified with Part A to pay for in hospital services and Part B to pay a premium of about $100 per month to Medicare. Unlike private insurance, Medicare pays for anything that is “medically necessary.” In 1997, Congress passed the Balanced Budget Act, which created Part C, or Medicare Advantage.

“The original idea was the private sector could better control costs,” said Wilson. “The purpose was to allow insurance companies to make money from Medicare without risk. They were required to furnish the same services as traditional Medicare, but did not have to honor the same co-pays, giving them flexibility. After 15 years, we’ve learned we get virtually nothing for the extra cost. The private sector cannot save money, because Medicare operates with about 2 percent overhead, while private insurance in Oklahoma can make up to 40 percent overhead by law. PPACA restricts that percentage to 20 percent for small groups and 15 percent for large groups, saving consumers from more excessive overhead for salaries, advertising, etc.”

Wilson said the remaining two-thirds of the Medicare cuts will come from reimbursement to hospitals and other providers.

“One of the best-kept secrets is the providers generally agreed to these cuts, because PPACA will ensure more paying customers, ceasing the necessity of managing risk by charging some people too much just to pay for those who can’t pay,” said Wilson. “In Oklahoma, each insured person, or her employer, currently pays almost $1,000 extra per year just to compensate for the uninsured. That’s almost $4,000 for a family of four. That’s $4,000 in payroll cost that can’t be used for raises or other employee benefits.”

Wilson said another “secret” is that most hospitals and providers want PPACA to survive.

“It’s the insurance companies that are pushing back; even though they will have a bunch of new customers, they don’t want to give up their excessive margins,” said Wilson.

Following the passage of PPACA, Medicare enrollees will now be offered additional wellness and prevention benefits, including wellness visits, cancer screenings, cardiovascular screenings, diabetes screening and self-management training, glaucoma screening, HIV screening, immunizations, medical nutrition therapy for beneficiaries with diabetes or renal disease, tobacco-use cessation counseling, screening for depression in adults and intensive behavioral therapy for obesity.

Tahlequah physician James Maddison, D.O., is a nephrologist, meaning he primarily treats patients with kidney diseases. Hethinks it is too early to tell how PPACA will affect Medicare coverage overall.

“A major portion of my practice, being a nephrologist, is on Medicare,” said Maddison. “Medicare is a significant player in the patient mix that I see. It’s too early to know how Medicare coverage and reimbursement will totally be in play. In Tahlequah, with the relationships involved with Davita [a dialysis unit] and Tahlequah City Hospital, I only see good service and continued care provided for our patients. Medicare changes might even focus on level of care and service that patients receive, and I am sure the service patients receive with TCH, Davita and Tahlequah Medical Group will continue to exceed expectations.”

Overall, Maddison said he believes PPACA will improve citizens’ health.

“The spirit and intent of the ACA is to extend high-quality care and coverages to more and more people and families,” said Maddison. “This should continue to drive better health for Americans. The conventional wisdom of preventive care should reduce and address chronic conditions before they come into play, rather than curtail treatments.”

Also, over the next 10 years, recipients of Part D - or prescription drug services – will find the “doughnut hole,” or coverage gap, will close.

Right now, patients pay out-of-pocket for monthly Part D premiums, and pay 100 percent of their drug costs until they reach the $310 deductible amount. After fulfilling the deductible, a patient will pay 50 percent for brand-name drugs and 86 percent for generic drugs, while the Part D plan pays the rest, until the total spent on an individual’s drugs reaches $2,830. Once the patient reaches $2,830, he has reached the “doughnut hole,” and will now be responsible for the full cost of his drugs until the total “catastrophic threshold” of $6,440 is reached, which is $3,610 annually. After hitting this annual limit, patients are only responsible for a small amount of the cost – usually 5 percent of the cost of the  drugs thereafter, which is known as “Medicare catastrophic coverage.”

Starting in 2013, under PPACA, patients will pay less and less for brand-name, Part D prescription drugs in the coverage gap. By 2020, the coverage gap will be closed, meaning a patient will only pay 25 percent of the costs of his prescription drugs until he reaches the annual out-of-pocket spending limit.

Wilson believes PPACA will provide higher levels of efficiency across the board, whether a person prescribes to private health insurance, Medicare or Medicaid.

“Concerns people have about a ‘board of bureaucrats’ deciding treatment, or about ‘limiting treatment,’ are unfounded,” said Wilson. “There will be an effort to use ‘best practices,’ and improve quality - both goals actually reduce costs while improving outcomes. Right now, insurance companies frequently require ‘pre-qualification’ or deny treatment or refuse to write policies or cancel policies - so why would we want to continue this system? As we discuss PPACA, we need to be aware every other industrialized country provides health care for their entire populations with better outcomes at 50-60 percent of our cost. Since health care consumes almost 18 percent of our economy, it is likely there are inefficiencies and, quite frankly, bad players involved in the zeal for big bucks. With decent management, we could shave $1 trillion from the $2.5 trillion cost, which is an amount equivalent to our deficit, while doing a better job of healthcare delivery.

“PPACA saved the insured money, insures the uninsured, immediately extends the life of Medicare by eight years, and most importantly, improves everyone’s health care.”

Text Only
Local News
  • SR-WalkaMile1.jpg Walk a Mile 2014

    Men squeezed into feminine footwear Saturday by the hundreds to walk in solidarity with women on the issue of sexual violence – and their clop-clop-clopping echoed down Muskogee Avenue.
    The fourth annual “Walk a Mile In Her Shoes” brought men to Norris Park, accompanied by their enthusiastic female supporters, to walk – and often wobble – in high heels over a mile-long course to raise funds for Help-In-Crisis.
    “It hurts every year,” said John Christie, a Sequoyah High School student participating in his third Walk a Mile. “I get home, sit down, blisters come up and the calves hurt. But it is worth it. It’s for a good cause.”

    April 22, 2014 2 Photos

  • adams-christopher.jpg Michigan man gets 13 years on plea to rape, sodomy of girl

    A 28-year-old Michigan man will spend about 13 years in an Oklahoma state prison after pleading guilty to four counts of first-degree rape and one count of sodomy involving a 13-year-old girl.
    Christopher Dale Adams, of Lake Orion, Mich., received a 13-year prison sentence for each of the five charges, to be followed by seven years suspended. All sentences will run concurrently.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • logan-amy.jpg Police take down pair on pot distribution charge

    Tahlequah police officers arrested a pair Sunday night for allegedly possessing marijuana with the intent to distribute it.
    Tahlequah Officer Cody Warren said police were asked to investigate when 35-year-old Amy N. Logan, of Tahlequah, allegedly took a family member’s car without permission.
    While Warren was speaking with the owners of the vehicle, Logan arrived along with 26-year-old Theoplilus James Mollie, of Tulsa.

    April 22, 2014 2 Photos

  • land-lisa.jpg Two nailed with meth, pot hidden in bag of chips

    Two people were arrested early Monday morning when Tahlequah police stopped a vehicle near Basin Avenue and found methamphetamine and marijuana hidden in a bag of chips.
    Tahlequah Officer Cory Keele said he noticed a Nissan heading north on Park Hill Road, and the vehicle later stopped in an intersection.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • gawf-johnny.jpg Nylon case doesn’t fool deputy; drug charges to be filed

    A Tahlequah man is jailed at the Cherokee County Detention Center after being arrested on drug possession charges.
    Deputy Michael Cates stopped Johnny Lee Gawf, 25, near Stick Ross Mountain Road and U.S. Highway 62. Gawf did not have his driver’s license and had a no-bond warrant for failure to pay.
    When Gawf was asked to step out of his vehicle, he allegedly reached into a pocket and pulled out a black nylon case, which he claimed to be a pocket knife. Gawf sat the case in the seat of the vehicle.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • ts-CN-citizenship.jpg Dual citizenship still OK for tribes

    It’s been almost a year since the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians in Oklahoma was forced to close its casino, leaving about 150 members without jobs.
    Right before the operations was shuttered, Cherokee Nation Principal Chief Bill John Baker offered a plan to absorb UKB employees, scheduling three employment registration meetings in September 2013.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • TPS to hold graduation at Doc Wadley, after all

    A letter obtained by the Tahlequah Daily Press states that graduation exercises for the Tahlequah High School Class of 2014 will be held at Doc Wadley Stadium on May 23.
    Tahlequah Public Schools received an invitation from the city and Northeastern State University to hold the graduation ceremony inside the NSU multipurpose event center, and the district was initially agreeable. But the necessity of limiting invitations to 10 or 15 per student because of seating concerns drew heavy criticism from seniors and parents.

    April 22, 2014

  • Woman allegedly went after relative, then cop

    Deputies say a 22-year-old woman assaulted a family member Saturday, then attacked an officer when he tried to arrest her.
    Deputy Bryan Qualls was sent to investigate the domestic disturbance at Hilltop Circle. Donna Wilder, the alleged victim, told Qualls that the suspect, Kaylynn Sharp, was hiding in the garage, and had struck her in the face several times.

    April 22, 2014

  • jn-city-pool.jpg City of Tahlequah progressing on bond projects

    Just more than a year after the city began collecting a sales tax funds for use on capital improvements, crews continue to work toward finishing several of the projects.
    “We’re going to deliver everything we said we would,” Tahlequah Mayor Jason Nichols said Friday.
    The $21-million-plus bond issue approved in 2013 includes about $10 million worth of street projects. South Muskogee Avenue will eventually be widened into a five-lane stretch; East Fourth Street’s widening project is underway; and West Fourth will become, at least in part, a three-lane road.
    Projects will also focus on parts of North Grand, East Allen, Bluff, Crafton, and North Cedar.

    April 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • duvall-dustin.jpg Four men charged with burglary

    Four local men are facing burglary and stolen-property charges in Cherokee County District Court.
    Prosecutors have charged the four men with second-degree burglary and knowingly concealing stolen property.

    April 21, 2014 3 Photos


How confident are you that the immunizations for infants and children are reasonably safe?

Not at all confident.
Somewhat confident.
Relatively confident.
Extremely confident.
     View Results
Tahlequah Daily Press Twitter
Follow us on twitter
AP Video
Bon Jovi Helps Open Low-income Housing in Philly Pipeline Opponents Protest on National Mall Hagel Gets Preview of New High-tech Projects S.C. Man Apologizes for Naked Walk in Wal-Mart New Country Music Hall of Fame Inductees Named 'Piles' of Bodies in South Sudan Slaughter New Yorkers Celebrate Cherry Blossom Blooms SCOTUS Hears Tv-over-Internet Case Justice Dept. Broadening Criteria for Clemency Chief Mate: Crew Told to Escape After Passengers 'Miss Meadows' Takes Holmes Back to Her Roots Biden: Russia Must Stop Talking, Start Acting David Moyes Out As Manchester United Manager Raw: Leopard Bites Man in India Iowa College Finds Beauty in Bulldogs High Court to Hear Dispute of TV Over Internet Stowaway Teen Forces Review of Airport Security