Tahlequah Daily Press

Local News

February 25, 2013

Oklahoma Supreme Court addresses Bosh case

TAHLEQUAH — The Oklahoma Supreme Court has answered several questions posed by the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Oklahoma, where a civil case alleges employees at the Cherokee County Detention Center used excessive force on a detainee nearly two years ago.

According to OSC Justice Yvonne Kauger’s formal response, the U.S. District Court in Muskogee was seeking clarification “concerning the remedies available to a plaintiff who brings an excessive force lawsuit... .”

Four questions were submitted to the Oklahoma Supreme Court, which reformulated the questions into three, according court documents.

The questions were posed as part of the court proceedings brought by Daniel Bosh against the Cherokee County Governmental Board Authority, Cherokee County Detention Center, and two CCDC employees.

Bosh alleges he was the victim of excessive force when he was being booked in at CCDC May 17, 2011. He claims he suffered severe injuries as a result of the incident, but was denied medical attention for several days.

In this month’s filing, Oklahoma Supreme Court justices wrote that “the facts presented by the parties in this Court are very limited and offer very little detail.”

The first issue addressed by justices relates to an alleged conflict between the Oklahoma Constitution, which protects citizens from unreasonable seizures; and the Oklahoma Governmental Tort Claims Act, which appears to allow CCGBA to “elude tort liability when its employees beat and injure a citizen who is detained at one of its facilities.”

CCGBA previously argued it cannot be held responsible for employees who exert excessive force against detainees, citing the tort-claims act that theoretically grants the authority immunization. Bosh argues that regardless of the tort-claim act, the state’s constitution protects citizens from being physically abused by employees of the state.

OSC justices acknowledged in their ruling that the OGTCA immunizes the state, counties and municipalities from liabilities arising out of the operation of a jail facility.

“This does not mean that injured tort victims are at the mercy of their captors to be beaten, assaulted, and left without medical attention without any remedy to deter such conduct,” the justices wrote.

Justices said the Oklahoma Governmental Tort Claims Act cannot be construed as providing complete immunization for violations of citizens’ constitutional rights.

They declared the Oklahoma constitution provides a private cause of action for excessive-force claims, despite requirements and limitations set forth by the OGTCA.

“[To provide complete immunization from liability] would not only fail to conform to established precedent which refused to construe the OGTCA as providing blanket immunity, but would also render the constitutional protections afforded the citizens of this state as ineffective, and a nullity,” justices said.

A second question addressed to the Oklahoma Supreme Court justices focused on whether their first answer should be applied to litigation filed before this month’s answer.

The Supreme Court decided to apply the decision retroactively to “help to maintain a proper balance” that allows law enforcement officials to constrain detainees as needed, but “without using unnecessary excessive force that can cause permanent injuries to detainees.”

“Retroactive application will only further and advance proper behavior,” justices wrote.

Justices also ruled that the common-law theory “respondeat superior” – which holds an employer liable for employees’ actions – should apply to municipal corporations under state law.

1
Text Only
Local News
  • plane-crash-1-a.jpg Plane crash victims recovering

    Two Arkansas men remained in a Tulsa hospital Monday after the plane they were flying crashed into a wooded area in Cookson.
    According to the Federal Aviation Administration, the 1946 Ercoupe 415 crashed under “unknown circumstances” about a mile from the Tenkiller Air Park in Cookson Saturday morning.
    The Oklahoma Highway Patrol says 75-year-old John McCreary and 85-year-old Albert Demarco Jr., both of Ozark, Ark., were flown from Cookson to St. John Medical Center in Tulsa.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • walker-terrance.jpg Man taken for blood sample confuses hospital with hotel

    Tahlequah police say an Austin, Texas, man stopped Saturday mistook a local hospital for a hotel when he was taken to have his blood drawn.
    Officer Cory Keele’s affidavit says 20-year-old Terrance Walker was driving south on Muskogee Avenue at about 2 a.m. Saturday, swerving from one line to another.
    Keele tried to stop the car near Muskogee and Chickasaw, and Walker eventually slowed to a stop near South Street.
    Walker opened the car door as Keele approached. The officer said Walker had dilated pupils.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • ennis-scottie.jpg Knife-cutting incident lands man in jail

    A Tahlequah man jailed for allegedly cutting a woman with a kitchen knife was released on a recognizance bond Monday.
    Scottie Lee Ennis, 42, was arrested after Officer Austin Yates was sent to Tahlequah City Hospital late Friday night.
    There, Yates spoke with Jennifer Pennell, who had apparently suffered a stab wound to her arm.
    Pennell told Yates she and her husband, Ennis, had gone to Dewain’s Place earlier in the evening, and while at the bar, a man bought her a drink.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • hawley-jeremy.jpg Tahlequah man bonds out after arrest for assault

    A 22-year-old Tahlequah man bonded out of jail Monday after his weekend arrest on domestic assault charges.
    Jeremy Hawley was booked into jail Sunday for domestic assault and battery in the presence of a minor and interfering with a 911 call.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Cherokee Nation law eases restrictions in gaming facilities

    The Cherokee Nation Tribal Council on Monday night voted to reduce regulations in its gaming facilities, but to conform to National Indian Gaming Commission minimum internal control standards.
    The measure ultimately passed 9-7, with District 1 Councilor Joe Byrd abstaining.
    Before discussion, Councilor Lee Keener moved to table the item, saying neither he nor members of the gaming commission had sufficient time to review the act. Councilor Cara Cowan-Watts seconded the motion, with a friendly amendment.

    April 15, 2014

  • Boy again caught with stolen items

    Cherokee County sheriff’s deputies say a juvenile caught with stolen property several times in the past was recently discovered to have more missing items.
    Deputies took a report over the weekend from a man who said his garage was burglarized while he was away from his home for an extended time. A number of items were taken, including an air compressor, leaf grinder, leaf blower, extension cords, drill-bit kit, a cordless drill, antique tools, a pressure washer, a machete, an aluminum ladder and a butane lighter torch.

    April 15, 2014

  • hughes-james.jpg Muskogee man caught with drugs at casino

    Cherokee Nation marshals arrested a Muskogee man Sunday after he was allegedly caught with drugs at the Cherokee Casino.
    Deputy marshals were called when security at the casino noticed a man drop a bag of a white, crystal-like substance.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Tahlequah man charged with hitting vehicle, fleeing

    Prosecutors have formally charged a Tahlequah man accused of hitting another vehicle in downtown Tahlequah and leaving the scene.

    April 15, 2014

  • sp-symposium-Child.jpg Child discusses survival of Native communities

    When Dr. Brenda Child, Ojibwe/Red Lake, tells people she is from the reservation at Red Lake, Minn., she explains, “We’re the ones who didn’t lose our lands.”
    Her tribe’s story is unusual among Native Americans, many of whom have been displaced throughout history. But history is complicated, she said. That’s why, as a historian, she is interested in “the small stor[ies].”
    “I’m someone who can’t really get a grasp of the big picture ... unless I look at the individual stories of people on the ground. How were they living? What shaped their lives?” she asked.

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • ts-Symposium-Leeds.jpg Developing food security, sovereignty

    When the Cherokees rebuilt their nation 150 years ago following the Trail of Tears, they immediately went to work re-establishing a government, along with higher education and court systems.
    Stacy Leeds, Cherokee citizen and dean of the College of Law at the University of Arkansas, said that while history reveres the Cherokee judges, scholars and lawmakers of the time, most Cherokee citizens were farmers.
    Leeds gave a presentation Friday about tribal governance, land use, food and agriculture police and economic development during the 42nd annual Symposium of the American Indian at Northeastern State University. The luncheon was hosted by the NSU Chapter of American Indian Students in Science and Engineering, and Leeds offered the AISES students food for thought about where their careers could be going.

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

Poll

What to you think of a state Legislature proposal to forbid cities from raising the minimum wage? Choose the closest to your opinion.

The federal government should set the minimum wage across the board.
States should be allowed to raise their minimum wages, but not cities.
Both states and cities should be allowed to raise their minimum wages.
Cities should be allowed to raise their mimum wages, but not states.
There should be no minimum wage at all.
Undecided.
     View Results
Tahlequah Daily Press Twitter
Follow us on twitter
AP Video
Stocks