Tahlequah Daily Press

Local News

July 11, 2013

High court challenge

TAHLEQUAH — The Cherokee Nation Supreme Court on Tuesday heard arguments in two cases about the recent tribal council election.

Former District 15 Tribal Councilor Meredith Frailey has petitioned the court for a runoff election, while at-large challenger Robin Mayes has asked the court to set a new election in his case.

According to certified election results, District 15 incumbent Meredith Frailey was narrowly defeated by Janees Taylor. Frailey earned 262 votes, compared to Taylor’s 289, or 50.70 percent of the ballots cast.

On Tuesday, James Proszek, council for Frailey, argued that irregularities in the conduct of the District 15 election resulted in 20 voters being improperly required to cast ballots outside their home district. Due to these irregularities, Proszek said, Taylor did not receive more than 50 percent of the votes in District 15.

As relief, Frailey is requesting the court order a runoff election be set between her and Taylor.

“This is about an integral part of the process,” said Proszek. “Twenty-two voters were denied their right to vote in their district or were allowed to vote in an improper district.”

Taylor and the Cherokee Nation Election Commission were both named in Frailey’s action, and both filed accompanying motions to defend their positions.

Don Bingham, Taylor’s attorney, made a motion to dismiss, saying Frailey’s allegations failed to meet the requirements necessary to affect the outcome of the election.

“They are arguing about votes that could have been cast [in the District 15 election], but weren’t, creating a mathematical uncertainty in the outcome,” said Bingham. “They have no legal underpinnings for saying that.”

Frailey’s case centered on 18 voters whose last registered addresses were post office boxes. After the tribe split the nation into 15 voting districts last year, the Cherokee Nation Election Commission was charged with making sure voters were reassigned to their proper districts.

A CNEC resolution issued in January stated registered voters with post office  boxes listed who failed to make address changes - giving a physical address - by the final registration date of April 1, would be placed in the district in which their post office boxes were located.

However, the CNEC was mandated by the redistricting law to make sure voters were properly assigned to districts, and extended making changes to registration information through the end of April.

Throughout the day’s proceedings, both sides called several witnesses, including CNEC Chairman Bill Horton, CNEC board member Carolyn Allen, CNEC Administrator Wanda Beaver, Frailey, Taylor’s field director Jared Johnson, and John Rose, a consultant hired to aid the tribe’s election commission with software updates for redistricting. Also called was Kathy Hines, director of the Center of Spatial Analysis at the University of Oklahoma; she aided the election commission in mapping for redistricting.

During her testimony, Frailey said she visited each of the post offices in District 15 to establish the 18 voters’ boxes were, indeed, within the district. She did not conduct any further investigation to obtain the physical address of the voters in question.

Johnson, who worked on Taylor’s campaign, said he conducted extensive research beginning Sunday, July 7, and ascertained most with post office boxes listed voted within the appropriate district they were assigned given their physical address.

“We must also point out that voters in all districts were not denied the right to vote,” said Bingham. “We’ve shown through testimony today that challenge ballots were available.”

Bingham’s motion to dismiss was denied, and after hearing testimony and summations, the justices retired to consider the evidence and will issue written order no later than close of business Friday.

In the second case heard by the court, at-large challenger Robin Mayes asked the court to void the results of the June 22 election, and order a new one for the at-large candidates. Certified election results indicate incumbent Jack Baker earned 51.64 percent - 739 votes – of the 1,439 ballots cast.

Mayes, represented by A.J. Garcia, asserts the CNEC, CN Registration Department and CN Attorney General Todd Hembree excluded “in excess of 4,000 Cherokee citizens,” from registering as citizens, while allowing several hundred of the same class - descendants of Freedmen - to vote and fully participate in the election.

Sara Hill, representing Hembree’s office, asked that Mayes’ motion be denied.

“The fact is, Mayes was defeated,” said Hill. “His claim in no way shows violation of election code or procedure. This, in fact, is not a proper election challenge, as the registrar - not the election commission - determines citizenship.”

Harvey Chaffin, attorney for CNEC, concurred.

“If you’re not a citizen,  if you don’t have a card, you can’t register to vote,” said Chaffin. “Citizenship is determined by the Cherokee Nation, not the election commission. We have allowed certain Freedmen to vote because they are registered citizens and voters. The federal case [to determine the acceptance of additional Freedmen as citizens] is still pending in federal court. The Cherokee Nation Election Commission is part of the federal case and is under federal order saying we will allow registered freedmen to vote.”

After deliberating in chambers for a short while, the justices returned and dismissed Mayes’ case, saying it failed to meet standards for an election challenge.

Text Only
Local News
  • svw-beagles-MAIN.jpg Going to the dogs

    Hounds at center stage for more than just Red Fern Festival

    Larry Blackman and Titus Blanket have always loved dogs, especially beagles. In their respective roles as president and vice president of the Cherokee County Beagle Club, they’ve turned that love into a passion.

    July 31, 2014 2 Photos

  • sanders-jeri.jpg Murder charge against mother of dead boy, 3, dismissed

    A first-degree murder charge has been dropped against a 37-year-old mother accused in the death of her 3-year-old son.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • supersalary.jpg Okla. superintendents paid comparatively well; teachers 46th lowest

    Administrators say they work year-round, have other duties

    As public education in Oklahoma continues to feel the pinch of a shrinking state budget, watchdog groups and district patrons across the state are asking whether superintendents are getting a disproportionate piece of the financial pie.

    July 31, 2014 2 Photos

  • Boards keep city, county afloat

    City and county officials rely on a variety of boards to oversee diverse and complex issues, and many of their members work behind the scenes to keep the wheels of government oiled and turning.
    The city of Tahlequah currently has 10 boards and three trust authorities. Cherokee County has two county-specific boards.

    July 31, 2014

  • HPWA contract raises gas to $3.99 a gallon

    The Hulbert Public Works Authority renewed its natural gas contract with Constellation Energy July 29, raising fuel prices to $3.99 per gallon for the next two years.

    July 31, 2014

  • Tourism Council OKs compensation

    The Tahlequah Area Tourism Council held its annual retreat Wednesday, and approved paying former Director Kate Kelly 100 hours of annual leave.

    July 31, 2014

  • rf-poker-run-main.jpg Poker run

    Fundraiser was in the cards for local philanthropic group

    It was perfect weather, with temperatures in the high 80s Saturday, as boaters filled their vessels with friends for a fun afternoon on Lake Tenkiller. A crowd gathered at Cookson Bend Marina, and folks lined up to support a local charity event.
    As fundraisers go, the Beta Sigma Phi Mu Omega Poker Run last Saturday could be considered huge success, as nearly $9,000 was collected.

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • bilbrey-anthony.jpg Man arrested for blackmailing woman for sex

    Cherokee County sheriff’s deputies put a man behind bars Monday night after he allegedly tried to blackmail a woman by threatening to post nude photos of her on the Internet if she did not meet him for sex.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • Peach_photo_2.jpg Peach crop lean, but fruit still available

    Summer is all about peaches in Porter – especially at Livesay Orchard.
    The Livesay Orchard is still busy a week after Porter’s annual peach festival. The orchard’s crop this year was cut in half from what had previously been expected, according to Kent Livesay, one of the owners of the orchard.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • jackson-jaymee.jpg Tot’s injuries prompt abuse charges for two local residents

    A Tahlequah couple was formally charged Tuesday with child neglect and child abuse after an 18-month-old girl was found with a number of injuries.

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos


Do you think "blue laws" related to Sunday alcohol sales in Oklahoma should be relaxed? Choose the option that most closely reflects your opinion.

Alcoholic drinks should be sold Sundays in restaurants and bars, and liquor stores should be open.
Alcoholic drinks should be sold Sundays in restaurants and bars only; liquor stores should stay closed.
Liquor stores should be open Sundays, but drinks should not be served anywhere on Sundays.
The law should remain as it is now; liquor stores should be closed, and drinks should be served on Sundays according to county option.
No alcohol should be sold or served publicly on Sundays.
     View Results
Tahlequah Daily Press Twitter
Follow us on twitter
AP Video
Couple Channel Grief Into Soldiers' Retreat WWI Aviation Still Alive at Aerodrome in NY Raw: Rescuers at Taiwan Explosion Scene Raw: Woman Who Faced Death Over Faith in N.H. Clinton Before 9-11: Could Have Killed Bin Laden Netanyahu Vows to Destroy Hamas Tunnels Obama Slams Republicans Over Lawsuit House Leaders Trade Blame for Inaction Malaysian PM: Stop Fighting in Ukraine Cantor Warns of Instability, Terror in Farewell Ravens' Ray Rice: 'I Made a Huge Mistake' Florida Panther Rebound Upsets Ranchers Small Plane Crash in San Diego Parking Lot Busy Franco's Not Afraid of Overexposure Fighting Blocks Access to Ukraine Crash Site Dangerous Bacteria Kills One in Florida Workers Dig for Survivors After India Landslide Texas Scientists Study Ebola Virus Smartphone Powered Paper Plane Debuts at Airshow Southern Accent Reduction Class Cancelled in TN